Pros of ansible

• Official repository with the core Ansible codebase
• Actively maintained with frequent updates and releases
• Comprehensive documentation and extensive community support

Cons of ansible

• Large codebase can be overwhelming for beginners
• Focuses on core functionality, not curated resources or extensions
• Steeper learning curve for contributors

Code comparison

ansible:

def run_playbook(self, playbook, inventory, **kwargs):
    pb = Playbook.load(playbook, variable_manager=self.variable_manager, loader=self.loader)
    plays = pb.get_plays()
    
    for play in plays:
        result = self._tqm.run(play)

awesome-ansible:

## Resources
- [Ansible Documentation](https://docs.ansible.com/)
- [Ansible Galaxy](https://galaxy.ansible.com/)
- [Ansible Blog](https://www.ansible.com/blog)

## Tutorials
- [Ansible for DevOps](https://www.ansiblefordevops.com/)
- [Ansible Tutorial for Beginners](https://www.guru99.com/ansible-tutorial.html)

The ansible repository contains the actual Ansible source code, while awesome-ansible is a curated list of Ansible resources, tools, and tutorials. The code snippets show this difference, with ansible featuring Python code for running playbooks, and awesome-ansible containing Markdown with links to various Ansible-related resources.

Pros of ansible-lint

• Actively maintained and developed by the Ansible team
• Provides specific linting and best practices checks for Ansible playbooks
• Integrates well with CI/CD pipelines for automated code quality checks

Cons of ansible-lint

• Focused solely on linting, not a comprehensive resource for Ansible
• Requires setup and configuration to use effectively
• May produce false positives or require customization for specific use cases

Code comparison

awesome-ansible:

## Resources
- [Ansible Documentation](https://docs.ansible.com/)
- [Ansible Galaxy](https://galaxy.ansible.com/)
- [Ansible Quickstart Video](https://www.ansible.com/resources/videos/quick-start-video)

ansible-lint:

# Example .ansible-lint configuration
warn_list:
  - '106'  # Role name does not match pattern
  - '208'  # File permissions unset or incorrect
exclude_paths:
  - .cache/
  - .github/

Summary

awesome-ansible is a curated list of Ansible resources, tools, and best practices, serving as a comprehensive reference for Ansible users. It covers a wide range of topics and is community-driven.

ansible-lint, on the other hand, is a specific tool for linting Ansible playbooks and roles. It focuses on enforcing best practices and identifying potential issues in Ansible code. While more limited in scope, it provides actionable feedback for improving Ansible playbooks.

Pros of ansible-for-devops

• Provides practical, real-world examples and complete playbooks
• Includes comprehensive documentation and explanations for each example
• Offers a more structured learning approach for Ansible beginners

Cons of ansible-for-devops

• Focuses primarily on specific use cases rather than a broad overview of Ansible resources
• May not cover as wide a range of topics as awesome-ansible
• Updates might be less frequent compared to a community-driven list

Code Comparison

awesome-ansible typically doesn't include code snippets, as it's a curated list of resources. In contrast, ansible-for-devops provides full playbooks and roles. Here's a brief example from ansible-for-devops:

- name: Ensure Apache is installed.
  apt:
    name: apache2
    state: present

- name: Copy custom Apache configuration.
  template:
    src: templates/apache.conf.j2
    dest: /etc/apache2/apache2.conf
  notify: restart apache

This code snippet demonstrates the practical, hands-on approach of ansible-for-devops, providing ready-to-use examples for common tasks like installing and configuring Apache.

Pros of AWX

• Full-featured web UI for managing Ansible workflows and inventories
• Built-in job scheduling and real-time job status monitoring
• Integrated user authentication and role-based access control

Cons of AWX

• More complex setup and maintenance compared to standalone Ansible
• Requires additional system resources to run
• Steeper learning curve for users new to Ansible

Code Comparison

AWX (Python):

from awx.main.models import Job

job = Job.objects.create(
    name="My Job",
    project=project,
    playbook="playbook.yml",
    inventory=inventory
)
job.launch()

awesome-ansible (YAML):

- name: My Task
  hosts: all
  tasks:
    - name: Execute command
      command: echo "Hello, Ansible!"

Summary

AWX is a comprehensive web-based solution for managing Ansible at scale, offering advanced features like job scheduling and access control. However, it comes with increased complexity and resource requirements. awesome-ansible, on the other hand, is a curated list of Ansible resources, providing a simpler approach for users who prefer working directly with Ansible playbooks and command-line tools. The choice between the two depends on the scale of your infrastructure and your team's specific needs.